Tech companies like Incopro and Netnames online counterfeits replica watches

Please use the sharing tools found via the email icon at the top of articles. Copying articles to share with others is a breach of FT.com T&Cs and Copyright Policy. Email licensing@ft.com to buy additional rights. Subscribers may share up to 10 or 20 articles per month using the gift article service. More information can be found at

In July, luxury brands won a significant victory in their battle with the billion-dollar online counterfeit industry. The Court of Appeal in London ruled that Richemont, owner of Cartier and many other prestigious labels, could ask internet service providers to block access to websites selling counterfeit goods. But Richemont did not build this case by itself: to detect those websites, Richemont had employed Incopro, an online brand protection service. The legal case related to eight websites including cartierloveonline.com, which was full of stolen brand imagery and was offering replica Cartier Love bracelets in white gold with four diamonds for £56. The real version costs £8,650.

Incopro uses a combination of techniques to target big offenders. These include sophisticated image-matching, where it scans for the false use of brand images and logos, and word searches such as “replica watch”. All the data are captured on a dashboard that brands can interact with and that presents clusters of sites linked by the same counterfeiters, allowing Incopro to target them in bulk.

By tracking the connections between those who advertise on Facebook and WeChat — a popular messaging service in China — and sell on marketplaces such as Taobao and Alibaba, Incopro can identify sellers of significant commercial size. That way, it can have a scalable impact. Once it has found the counterfeiter, it then targets sellers in one swoop: Incopro alerts online marketplaces, internet service providers and domain name registries and asks them to close the sites down, 24 hours a day.

You cannot fault the fraudsters for their chutzpah. One counterfeit watch website operating today purports to be a family-owned business with professional images of TAG Heuer and Breitling replica watches alongside its own blog, Twitter feed and Instagram page. It accepts PayPal and even has a bogus contact address and phone number. If discounts of up to 80 per cent do not ring alarm bells, coupled with the distinctly functional web experience — no close-ups of clasps and dials here — you could be fooled.

Many are fooled, or are seeking out counterfeits willingly. At Europe’s borders, watches are the most valuable type of fake good seized: €92m worth in 2014, according to the European Commission, with jewellery adding another €13m. But this is dwarfed by the US, where counterfeit watches outlet and jewellery with a value of $582m were seized in 2015, up from $380m the year before. On one day in June 2015, 175,000 watches and related forgery tools were seized, worth a total of $100m.

While online counterfeits were once limited to rogue websites and auction platforms such as eBay, fraudsters are now selling through Alibaba, with its 434m active users. Social media and mobile apps now present the biggest challenges, as counterfeiters raise the profile for replicas by using paid searches on Google or popular hashtags on Instagram, for example. Seeing a cheap watch advertised on Facebook earns an element of trust with consumers who may therefore be more inclined to purchase.

“It is impossible to eliminate [brand infringement] completely,” says Stuart Fuller, director of commercial operations at Netnames, an online brand protection service whose clients include Danish jeweller Georg Jensen. “A counterfeiter will use every single digital marketing tool exactly the same as a genuine brand owner: paid search; social media; they will use apps; they will use all the tools a brand tries to drive traffic. The difference is [customers] might get a substandard product or nothing at all.”

“You want to hit all [a counterfeiter’s] operations in one go,” says Simon Baggs, an intellectual property lawyer at Wiggin and co-founder of Incopro. “He may have 100 shops on eBay and Amazon and Alibaba. So you add all these to the basket and send a notice at the end of the day. This way he wakes up in the morning and all his operations are gone. You really start to hit his business.

“For any substantial brand, the number of fakes can be vast,” he adds, estimating that a brand may typically have 3,000-5,000 sites selling counterfeit goods. “The best combination is legal enforcement and technology. You can’t do it all through

Please use the sharing tools found via the email icon at the top of articles. Copying articles to share with others is a breach of FT.com T&Cs and Copyright Policy. Email licensing@ft.com to buy additional rights. Subscribers may share up to 10 or 20 articles per month using the gift article service. More information can be found at

At Incopro, a typical £100,000 campaign can reduce the volume of replicas on marketplaces such as Amazon or eBay by 60 per cent over six months, Mr Baggs says. An operation to track copies of a £1,000 dress, being offered at £125, removed 800,000 from those sites. He says 40 per cent of Incopro’s business comes from luxury companies.

Tiffany & Co is taking a different approach. It has developed its own mobile app for employees, called FakR, that allows them to report replicas by posting photos of street vendors hawking fakes watches or by sending links to questionable online auction listings. Internal reports have surged 60 per cent since it was launched last year and close to three-quarters of reports are actionable, says the company.

Fighting Replica Watches With Hidden Laser Images & Nanostructuring

Luxury replica watch makers are constantly fighting against fake and replica watches that damage the authentic watch market in a range of ways. While I have personally suggested that few fake watches are passable by experts as authentic items, there are a number of situations where being able to unequivocally verify a timepiece as being “real” is important. You can read more about the truth about replica watches here. Brands such as Rolex and others have engaged in special techniques to battle replicas for years. A common tactic–such as those used by currency printers–is to produce elements in the watch which are difficult or impossible to copy. A new technique to do so uses something called CLR-LIGA to battle against replica watches, and it will start being used by the Swiss watch maker Carl F. Bucherer soon on all of their in-house made mechanical watch movements.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Carl F. Bucherer is working with fellow Swiss company, Mimotec SA, that developed the CLR-LIGA process, which is actually a combination of two relatively recent technologies. “CLR” stands for “covert laser readable,” which is an interesting way of hiding images that only lasers can read. Basically, a laser is pointed at a particular spot where a CLR image has been produced. The covert hidden image is visible in the bounced light, and there are special scanners designed to read CLR images which are very small and are not visible to the naked eye.

Mimotec uses Laser LIGA technology to produce the small CLR images on the surfaces of watch movements. LIGA is a German acronym for a process that uses nano-structuring to shape the surface of materials on a very small level. LIGA is used to produce the CLR images, and the combination allows for an almost impossible to replicate image that, when combined with a laser scanning device, can display a unique image which lasts forever and helps identify authentic products from replicas. It is unclear whether or not Carl F. Bucherer will be using this technology to place individual serial numbers on its watch movements or more general “brand signatures.”

A problem I have with Swiss luxury watch brands focusing on these niche techniques to battle watch replicas is the message it can have to some consumers. If Carl F. Bucherer has to resort to hidden nano-structures in order to battle fakes it sounds like the fakes out there are pretty good. That couldn’t be father from the truth. It is true that I personally represent a more sophisticated class of watch lover, but I don’t think that most people putting a real or fake Carl F. Bucherer movement next to each other would be fooled by the replica model. In fact, even if fake watches Carl F. Bucherer replica watches exists, I don’t think anyone is clever enough to copy the look and feel of their in-house made movements.